This is a letter from us, not from the Peacewalk. It is published by Zetareh and it sets out a disagreement with the organisers of the walk. Everything official about the walk is at peacewalk.info. Our page for the Hungarian leg is here, and it stays up.

Hind Rajab never had a choice

An open letter to the Peacewalk

To Rikko Voorberg and the organisers of the Peacewalk to Al-Quds/Jerusalem

Masud Beroz · Zetareh · 24 August 2026


I wrote to you privately on 22 August and asked one question: do you and your group condemn Zionism, apartheid and colonialism? I said I would publish the question and your answer, whatever it was, unedited. No answer came, and I take that at face value — you are walking across Europe with your family, and a stranger's deadline is not your obligation.

So this is not published against your silence. It is published because the question outlived it, and because people here have told me personally that they intended to walk beside you, on the strength of what we wrote about you. They gave me their word directly, and they are owed my reasoning in return.

Let me say first what this is not. I am not against what you are doing. Thousands of people walking across a continent for peace is not a thing to be sneered at, and I have no interest in adding to the noise around anyone who tries something difficult. Your walk is not a Zionist project — I checked, because it was suggested to me and I would rather check than assume, and I will come back to what I found.

My disagreement is with one thing only, and it is this:

Refusing to take sides in obvious cases of human rights violation and crimes against humanity is itself taking a side.

To put it as plainly as I hold it: declining to hold the invader and the perpetrator of genocide responsible for the war and the bloodshed — and instead naming revenge and human emotion as the cause — is a disservice to justice and to peace. That is my personal view, and the rest of this letter is my attempt to show my working.

Your own materials say the walk "is not aligned with any specific political solution." I understand the reasoning. I want to explain, as precisely as I can, why that position is not the neutral ground it appears to be — and why the disagreement is about method rather than about your sincerity.

Whose peace

Martin Luther King, writing from the Birmingham jail, named the obstacle to freedom not as the Klansman but as those "more devoted to order than to justice; who prefer a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice."

Desmond Tutu — whose daughter Mpho stands behind your walk — put it shorter: "If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor."

In September 2025 the UN Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. Amnesty International reached the same conclusion in December 2024. The International Court of Justice has ordered provisional measures. Your walk ends in Al-Quds. Its final thousand kilometres pass through the consequences of those findings.

A walk that arrives there without naming occupation offers reconciliation to people who have not been asked whether they want reconciliation or an end to what is being done to them. Forgiveness offered before justice is a request made of the injured.

Peace is not a choice everyone is free to make

On 29 January 2024 a five-year-old girl called Hind Rajab was in a car leaving Gaza City with her relatives. Six of them were killed. She survived the first shooting, alone among their bodies, and spent about three hours on the telephone to the Palestine Red Crescent asking to be collected. The Red Crescent waited for Israeli authorisation and took the route it was given. The two paramedics sent for her, Yusuf Zeino and Ahmed al-Madhoun, were killed by tank fire when they arrived.

Forensic Architecture counted 335 bullet holes in that car, placed Israeli tanks between 13 and 23 metres from it, and found no evidence of any armed exchange. For two and a half years the Israeli military denied that any of its forces were even in the area. On 19 August 2026 it reversed that denial: it admitted its troops fired on the car and on the ambulance, and opened a criminal investigation into both — the first criminal probe of troop conduct in the Gaza war. It was reported that day by CNN, TIME and NPR, among others.

That child was never offered a choice between love and hate. No walk, no vigil and no change of heart was available to her. The only choice in that street belonged to the people in the tank, and to those who put them there, and to the governments that keep supplying the means.

I raise it because it is the plainest test of the framing. Any account of this conflict which asks both sides to choose peace has to explain what Hind Rajab was being asked to choose.

Here is what troubles me most, and it is not about you personally.

The framing of peace as a choice between love and hate implies that the choice is available to everyone equally. It is not. A child under bombardment has no choice to make. The choice belongs to those who hold the power to stop — and to the far smaller number who profit while it continues.

When peace is presented as a change of heart, the machinery that produces war becomes invisible: the arms contracts, the export licences, the political cover. Eisenhower warned about that machinery on his way out of office. Smedley Butler, a serving major general, called it a racket. This is not a fringe reading of how wars are sustained.

A walk that refuses to name who profits leaves the machinery untouched, and asks the powerless to change their hearts.

"Revenge" is the wrong word, and the wrong word matters

There is a vocabulary around this walk that I have to object to plainly: the framing of what is happening as revenge, retaliation, a cycle of violence to be broken.

Revenge describes a mood. Wars are conducted through budgets, doctrine, appropriations, munitions contracts, reservist call-ups and target lists. Ministries do not have feelings. And settlement expansion in the West Bank has continued without interruption for decades, which no theory of retaliation explains, because it began long before there was anything to retaliate for.

What the word does is convert policy into passion. Passion is spontaneous, excusable, and self-limiting — it burns itself out, and nobody is required to intervene. Policy is chosen, funded and continued until somebody stops it. To call a programme "revenge" is to describe something that will end on its own.

And a misnamed cause produces a useless remedy. If the cause is anger, the cure is forgiveness, and the request is addressed to the people under the bombs. If the cause is a programme, the remedy is to stop the programme, and the request goes somewhere else entirely — to governments, to arms exporters, to the states supplying the means.

I am not saying feeling plays no part. Public appetite for retaliation is real, and it widens what a government may do. But that is consent, not cause — and consent is manufactured, which brings me to the next point.

How hate is manufactured, and by whom

Hatred between peoples is rarely spontaneous. It is produced, and the production is studied.

Research on competitive victimhood — Noor, Shnabel, Nadler — shows that the more a group sees itself as the ultimate victim, the less it can perceive another's suffering, and the more force it will licence in its own defence. Daniel Bar-Tal, an Israeli scholar writing about his own society, mapped the full apparatus: the justness of one's own goals, security above all other values, delegitimisation of the opponent, and victimhood held as permanent. He called the result a siege mentality.

Fear is the instrument. Victimhood is the product. And the product is manufactured most efficiently by those who need consent for what they are already doing.

This applies to everyone, including us. It is not a claim that one people is deceived and another is clear-sighted. It is a claim about how consent for violence is produced anywhere — which is exactly why a peace movement that does not name the producers is working on the symptom.

The symmetry

You place an Israeli and a Palestinian side by side, each of whom has lost family, and you say: look, they refuse revenge. I do not doubt them, and I will not question the grief of anyone who has buried their parents.

But symmetry between two grieving people is not symmetry between the parties. One side has a state, an army, an alliance and a press apparatus. The other is under occupation. Treating their narratives as equivalent is not neutrality — it is a subsidy to the larger machine, however gently it is offered.

The taxpayer had no choice either

There is a second person in this who was never offered the choice, and they are closer to home.

A European or American taxpayer whose money paid for those bullets was not consulted. They did not choose between love and hate, or between revenge and forgiveness. Their money was allocated by governments, through military aid and export licences, and the first many of them heard of it was on the news. Asking that person to change their heart is as misdirected as asking it of the child in the car — because the decision was never theirs either.

But it was somebody's. And here I want to point at something done in your own country, because it is the clearest answer to everything I have written above.

In late 2023 three Dutch organisations took the Dutch state to court over the transfer of F-35 parts to Israel. In February 2024 the appeals court in The Hague ordered the Netherlands to stop, finding a clear risk that the parts would be used in serious violations of international humanitarian law. The Supreme Court set that order aside in October 2025 on separation-of-powers grounds — and required the responsible minister to reassess the licence against the same risk, within six weeks. The Netherlands has kept the halt in place regardless, on the view that resuming the exports would be unreasonable in the present circumstances.

That is what naming the mechanism looks like. It was done by ordinary Dutch citizens, in a Dutch court, against their own government, and it interrupted a supply line. Nobody had to change their heart. Somebody had to identify a licence, a shipment and a legal obligation, and say so out loud.

Your walk left Amsterdam. I cannot reconcile that with a refusal to name anything.

What is not in dispute

As I said at the start: the accusation put to me does not survive contact with the record. You write Al-Quds before Jerusalem. You permit no national flags. You are endorsed by Mpho Tutu and Jan Pronk. Nothing in the record supports the accusation, and I will not make it.

What I found instead is a considered refusal to align — and I understand why. You have borders to cross that I do not. A stated position could end the walk before Turkey. That is a real argument and I respect the people making it.

We simply cannot join it. Those who walk with us hold that apartheid, occupation and colonialism are the cause of this bloodshed rather than its background, and a walk that will not say so cannot carry them, whatever it carries.

What stands

Our page for the Hungarian leg stays up. It exists so that somebody in Esztergom or Tahitótfalu can find out the walk passes their town in time to join it — which your own site did not tell them. It states plainly that it is not yours. It will not be taken down because we disagree with you, and nothing in this letter is asked of the people walking.

If you answer, we will publish your answer in full, unedited, and without commentary. That offer does not expire.

Hind Rajab never had a choice. Neither did the paramedics sent for her, nor the people whose taxes paid for the rounds fired into that car. The choice belonged to those who will not be walking to Al-Quds, and who are not asked to.

Walk safely. I mean that.

I will not be walking with you, and this is why.

I do not choose to feel good about myself for having chosen love and peace. I choose to feel what Hind Rajab felt in the last minutes of her short life.

Masud Beroz Zetareh